Skip to content
May 24, 2025
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • Whatsapp
Indian Law Watch

Indian Law Watch

Healthcare Laws & Compliance Focus

Primary Menu
  • Home
  • About us
  • ANALYSIS
    • PRACTICE AREAS
    • GUEST AUTHOR
  • Videos
  • STUDENTS CORNER
    • INTERSHIPS & OPPORTUNTIES
  • LAW LIBRARY
    • Acts of Parliament
    • RECENT AMENDMENTS
    • LAW COMMISSION
    • SUPREME COURT UPDATES
  • PRESS RELEASES
  • Citizen Connect
    • SHARE YOUR LEGAL QUERIES
  • Legal Events Corner
    • CALL FOR PAPERS
    • CONFERENCE AND OTHER EVENTS
    • Events
  • PHOTO GALLERY
Watch
  • SUPREME COURT UPDATES

SC reserves verdict on reconsideration of 1998 judgement granting immunity to lawmakers from prosecution

A seven-judge bench of the Supreme Court on Thursday reserved its verdict on reconsideration of its 1998 judgement which had held that MPs and MLAs enjoy immunity from prosecution for taking bribe to make a speech or vote in legislature.
sameerlakra October 6, 2023 2 min read
immunity to MPs and MLAs
FacebookXPinterestLinkedInWhatsApp

The constitution bench headed by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud reserved the verdict after hearing a battery of senior lawyers including Attorney General R Venkataramani and Solicitor General Tushar Mehta.

A seven-judge bench of the Supreme Court on Thursday reserved its verdict on reconsideration of its 1998 judgement which had held that MPs and MLAs enjoy immunity from prosecution for taking bribe to make a speech or vote in legislature.

The constitution bench headed by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud reserved the verdict after hearing a battery of senior lawyers including Attorney General R Venkataramani and Solicitor General Tushar Mehta.

The larger bench is reconsidering the 1998 verdict delivered in the JMM bribery case by a five-judge bench by which the MPs and MLAs were granted immunity from prosecution for taking bribe to make a speech or vote in legislature. The apex court is revisiting the judgement 25 years after the JMM bribery scandal rocked the country.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, while arguing the matter, urged the court to not go into the immunity aspect under Article 105 of the Constitution.

“The offence of bribery is complete when a bribe is given and accepted by the lawmaker. It can be tackled under the Prevention of Corruption Act,” the law officer said.

“Neither the majority nor minority (judgement of 1998) examined the issue from this perspective. The short question, on which present reference is based, is whether the offence of bribery is complete outside the House. If it is, this court does not need to go into the question of immunity,” the law officer said.

On Wednesday, the court said it will examine whether the immunity granted to lawmakers from prosecution for taking bribes to make a speech or vote in Parliament and state legislatures extends to them even if criminality is attached to their actions.

Article 105(2) stipulates that no member of Parliament shall be liable to any proceedings in court in respect of anything said or any vote cast in Parliament or any committee thereof. A similar provision exists for MLAs under Article 194(2).

A five-judge constitution bench had in its majority verdict delivered in the PV Narasimha Rao versus CBI case had held in 1998 that parliamentarians have immunity against criminal prosecution for any speech made and vote cast inside the House under Article 105(2) and Article 194(2) of the Constitution.

The Rao government, which was in a minority, had survived a no-confidence vote with the help of the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) Lok Sabha MPs who had accepted bribes to back his dispensation.

 

Source: MoneyControl

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About The Author

sameerlakra

See author's posts

Tags: immunity JMM Member of Legislative Assembly Member of Parliament MLA MP PV Narasimha Rao Supreme Court

Continue Reading

Previous: Freebies ahead of polls: SC takes note of PIL, seeks responses from MP, Rajasthan govts
Next: Unfortunate permanent State Mental Health Authority not constituted, says Delhi HC; seeks Health Secretary’s presence

Related News

Senior Citizen
1 min read
  • SUPREME COURT UPDATES

Rights of a senior citizen to claim back their transferred property under Maintenance and Welfare of the Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007

Indian Law Watch 1 month ago
Freedom of Speech (Website)
2 min read
  • SUPREME COURT UPDATES

Police Have Duty To Protect Freedom Of Speech: Supreme Court

Indian Law Watch 2 months ago
Railway Catering
2 min read
  • SUPREME COURT UPDATES

Supreme Court Directs Indian Railways to Implement CVC Report on Catering Fraud

Indian Law Watch 3 months ago
May 2025
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  
« Apr    

GNLU Essay Competition
3 min read
  • CONFERENCE AND OTHER EVENTS

GNLU proudly Unveils the 6th V.S. Mani Memorial National Essay Competition 2025 on Air and Space Jurisprudence – A Premier Platform for Visionary Legal Minds

Indian Law Watch 1 day ago
Pharma Oversight
2 min read
  • IN THE NEWS

₹1.19 Cr Pharma Sponsorship Audit — Irregularities Surface, Soft Law Limitations Noted

Indian Law Watch 4 days ago
NEW ADDITION (Website)
2 min read
  • PRESS RELEASES

Raunaq Bahadur Mathur embarks on a New Chapter as Partner, amplifying Saraf & Partners’ Dispute Resolution Arsenal #2

Indian Law Watch 7 days ago
NLU Image
4 min read
  • CALL FOR PAPERS

CALL FOR PAPERS | SOLVENTIA – JOURNAL OF INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY LAWS-NLU

Indian Law Watch 7 days ago
ELP (Website)
2 min read
  • PRESS RELEASES

Economic Laws Practice (ELP) Uses Vecflow to Scale Legal Work, and Lead in Legal AI Innovation

Indian Law Watch 3 weeks ago
Cough SYRUP (Website)
2 min read
  • IN THE NEWS
  • UNCATEGORIZED

Child Safety First: Delhi High Court and Central Government Tighten Rules on Cough Syrup and Cold Medicines for Children Below 4 Years

Indian Law Watch 4 weeks ago
  • CONTACT US
  • Event Post
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • Whatsapp
Copyright © All rights reserved. | MoreNews by AF themes.
Cleantalk Pixel